Dear All I agree with Mark's three conclusions with a few proposed changes to the second and third points:- 1) Pundits can fly as intermediate with 10%...
Hi All, Sorry but I will not be around on Saturday (wife's birthday!!), but will be there Sunday and Monday. In my absence Ken Woods will be deputising. ...
Hi All, Looking forward to seeing as many of you as possible this coming weekend!! First briefing will be as usual at 10am on Saturday. I am organising a BBQ -...
Rolf Tietema
rolf.tietema@...
Apr 29, 2009 10:07 am
397
Miriam Could you put the new rules we discussed yesterday on the web so we can all agree to them being trialed at Saltby? Thanks. Chris...
Hi Miriam, Point 3: As stated I think this is as per the old rules. i.e. not flown a 300km prior to April 1st of the year you are competing in. Do you mean ...
Does anyone else think that having come in the top half in a nationals or having flown a 750 a bit OTT for the pundit on an interclub league. I thought this...
Hi Guys I think Miriam must have slipped with the keyboard - there was a doubt at the meeting you kindly allowed me to sit in on, as to what the current rule...
Colin I keep sending messages and they keep bouncing back to this Group. Is there a reason for this? Is anyone else having the same problem, as I am finding it...
Colin Regarding the new pundit rules. There were a number of people sitting around the table at HUS and a number of conversations, however I think everyone...
Chris What you are saying now I think is different to the post that Miriam made - there is one word difference - NOT (copy of Miriam's post) Pundit - anyone...
Hi Guys Oops - Chris has made an error in his wording now - Miriam has it correct - better I think to define what constitutes an Intermediate. Dont forget...
Dear all, There appear to be several different conversations going on at the moment so in an attempt to bring them all together, please see below: 1. A Novice...
Hi Everyone I am sure Miriam meant OR but I do feel that it was decided that more than 1 Regional's put you in Intermediate for following year and not more...
Dear All Having thrown in deliberate mistake in my last communication (well spotted Chris!) I recall the discussion regarding a pilot's move from Novice to...
Dear All Thanks for spotting my deliberate mistake Chris - just checking everyone was reading the new rules carefully! During the conversation at HUS it was...
So, if you have done a 750 or finished in the top half of a national you are a pundit if you have done a 300 or competed in 2 regionals you are an intermediate...
Wouldn't this be better in reverse to illustrate that pilots of lower experience may always move up a class as required or wished. This is how the original...
Hi Julian They have to be OR's otherwise, as an example, a pilot who never enters Regional's will always remain a Novice even if he/she flies a 1000km as ...
Sorry Russell - I agree with Julian's logic, based on the fact your rules have ORs as well as NOTs. So by your rules below, for example, anyone who has NOT...
Rolf Tietema
rolf.tietema@...
May 8, 2009 12:33 pm
418
Hi Russell, I agree with the intention but as written it is:- Novice: A pilot who has not done A OR not done B OR not done C meaning a pilot not having done B...
You wouldn't believe how hard it is to write three sentences or misinterpret the same three sentences :-) I didn't get the highest grade in English "O" level...
I have always been a fan of NANDs and NORs...but simply put, the problem is we are trying to start with defining a Novice as a function of what they have not...
I like this but we need to add a few more words for clarity:- If you have done a UK 750 or finished in the top half of a National (excl Juniors) in the last 10...
The good news is that everyone seems to be in general agreement with the principles involved. Chris L's last rendition below has two issues:- 1 It doesn't...
