OK, I must have confused it with another reference -- possibly to an Australian group. I'll have another look. thx
Dr. Mark Bonta Associate Professor of Geography Division of Social Sciences Kethley 226, PO Box 3264 Delta State University Cleveland, MS 38733 Tel. 662.846.4096 [w]; 843.6205 [h]; Fax: 662.846.4099 Alternate email: mbonta@...
From: martin_t_walsh <mtw30@...> To: Ethnoornithology@... Sent: Sunday, May 10, 2009 3:28:07 AM Subject: [Ethnoornithology] Re: Firebirds!?
Mark, I can't see any statement like that in Birds of my Kalam Country. Here's the paragraph about Black Kites (square brackets in the original; the /n/ of anmt is a velar nasal that I can't reproduce here):
"Anmt or kob-bg-ket [the Black Kite, Milvus migrans] is another bird which hunts in the open country and the gardens, taking rats and snakes and worms from the ground. It is dark brown, partly black on the under-surface of its wings. I can't translate anmt, but kob-bg-ket means 'it haunts the burnt-off grassland'. When large areas of grass are burnt, this bird sometimes appears and catches small animals as they try to escape from the fire, and picks up dead creatures that the fire has left." (Majnep and Bulmer 1977: 144)
That's all there is in the text about the behaviour of Black Kites (and nothing like it in descriptions of other raptors, not that I can see with a
quick scan).
Martin
--- In Ethnoornithology@ yahoogroups. co.uk, Mark Bonta <markabonta@. ..> wrote: > > I saw a ref online to Birds of My Kalem Country, where the kite was linked to fire not only because it swooped around active burns, but also the way it moved its legs/talons appeared like the movements humans start to make fire. Can you check that (I don't have access to the book)? > > mb > > Dr. Mark Bonta > Associate Professor of Geography > Division of Social Sciences > Kethley 226, PO Box 3264 > Delta State University > Cleveland, MS 38733 > Tel. 662.846.4096 [w]; 843.6205 [h]; Fax: 662.846.4099 > Alternate email: mbonta@... > >
Dear all, Just a quick note to see if there is sufficient intererst for me to propose a symposium session on Ethnoornithology at this Year's Society of...
Just got a review copy of Krech's Spirits of the Air: Birds & American Indians in the South. Looks fantastic. I'll post a link to my review when I've got it...
See the Questions and Answers section in savanna.cdu.edu.au/downloads/tropical78.pdf My question is whether any birds in the world purposefully start fires to...
Re kites as "firebirds" - I can see a number of references to this on the internet, e.g. in an article on the domestication of fire in the journal *Human...
Dear Mark & Martin, Apologies for not replying earlier to this interesting point - and though I know that I mentioned this while I was recently with you in ...
I saw a ref online to Birds of My Kalem Country, where the kite was linked to fire not only because it swooped around active burns, but also the way it moved...
Mark, I'm away from home but will be back there on about the 21st or 22nd of this month - so if I don't remember please feel free to remind me then! Bob ... ...
Well, here's the latest from me. Audubon is letting me go, tomorrow will be my last day here. So I'll have more time to work on my book on urban birds as well...
Dear Rob:Sorry to hear about Audubon's loss. Wishing you the very best. I am keen to learn more about your "Eagles in Mesoamerican Cultures" paper. Do keep...
Dear Rob, Audubon's loss may be a gain for the rest of us...I suppose it supports the idea that you should never go on holiday.. Seriously though, it is always...
Dear Bob and others, I am sorry too to think of you leaving Audubon - I love the EO being talked about all over the place. In the meantime, I am so glad of...
Thanks LoraKim. I'll be doing more on birds and the ancient Maya over the next year. Not a lot pulled together in a meaningful way yet, but lots scattered...
Hi all, I'm part of a project looking at language change in hunter-gatherer communities and as part of that we're looking into flora and fauna terminology....
Mark, I can't see any statement like that in Birds of my Kalam Country. Here's the paragraph about Black Kites (square brackets in the original; the /n/ of...
OK, I must have confused it with another reference -- possibly to an Australian group. I'll have another look. thx Dr. Mark Bonta Associate Professor of...
Does anyone have quick access to this article? It apparently references Milvus: http://www.jstor.org/pss/673006 * A Remarkable Case of Tool-Using in a Bird *...
A Remarkable Case of Tool-Using in a Bird Author(s): Ashley Montagu Source: American Anthropologist, New Series, Vol. 72, No. 3 (Jun., 1970), p. 610 Published...
Thanks!! As I said before, if this kind of behavior were -- I hate to say 'confirmed' because we get into some sticky language -- but at least acceptable to...
Mrk et al, I have a copy of the Lockwood book with the reference that Montagu uses - but it is 1,000km away at home. I'll be in Adelaide in a week or so and...
Here's a counterpoint to the Black Kite as "firebird" -- ostriches as "fire extinguishers"!! The following passage is from notes written by Silas Kibwece in...
To the Kiadel (spelling?) of Bentick Island in the Gulf of Carpentaria the Black-shouldered Kite was the Fire Hawk. One of my students would always have one in...