Sign In
New User? Sign Up
clairseach · cląirseach
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can search the group for older messages.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Scotlands Music with Phil Cunningham   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #781 of 1270 |
Re: Scotlands Music with Phil Cunningham

Well I agree mostly, it was nice in a 'raising national conciousness'
kind of way but Phil was very full of himself, he has a very odd
sense of appropriate harmony and accompaniment, perhaps that is 'all
the rage' in traditional music today. Catriona McKay was very - dare
I say - funky - or even groovy? - but I was not sure how 'Scottish'
in any sense her style was, and I was amazed how she snapped into
harp geek mode to explain all kinds of mind numbing technicalities -
explains somewhat the garbled accounts I recieved from non-musicians
who had obviously been trying to grab factoids from the rush of
jargon - even I didn't understand everything she was talking about!
It was kind of sad seeing Phill drooling over the harps in the museum
and saying 'how did they ever make such finely crafted objects' and
'I wish I could have heard them being played' when there is a most
exquisite working replica not an hour up the coast... ah well... Also
did anyone note the loving close up of the modern display stand in
the middle of the Lamont sequence?
Back to not watching telly at all, normal service will be resumed asap.

And what about that Gaelic singer on Skye???

I would have thought you would like the driving scenes Mary!

Simon





Wed Nov 28, 2007 6:27 pm

simonchadwick
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #781 of 1270 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

http://www.bbc.co.uk/scotland/music/tv/ I didnt see it but heard there were harps in it Its repeated on Tuesday 7pm Anyone else in Scotland been watching?...
simon@...
simonchadwick
Offline Send Email
Nov 26, 2007
12:54 pm

Hi All, Just been to the link Simon posted if you go down the page you can watch a snippet of Catriona McKay on the Harp accompanied by a man on a lute (I...
Hannah Brome
hjbrome
Offline Send Email
Nov 26, 2007
2:56 pm

The preamble leading up to the harp was fine, good pictures of some of the stones with correct dates and so on, but the part with actual harper turned into the...
sanger_keith
Offline Send Email
Nov 27, 2007
12:25 pm

Unfortunately I only caught the second half this evening. I agree with you Keith, I also found that annoying, espescially when Ms. McKay said the clarsach was...
Hannah Brome
hjbrome
Offline Send Email
Nov 27, 2007
8:35 pm

Well I agree mostly, it was nice in a 'raising national conciousness' kind of way but Phil was very full of himself, he has a very odd sense of appropriate...
simon@...
simonchadwick
Offline Send Email
Nov 28, 2007
6:27 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! UK. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help