Sign In
New User? Sign Up
gevincountdown · Gevin's Countdown Group
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can search the group for older messages.

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
All-time great league   Message List  
Reply | Forward Message #9268 of 9304 |
Re: All-time great league

Here's an old top 20 list I came up with. It seems that Paul Gallen,
Mark Tournoff, Conor Travers, Paul Howe and Matthew Shore have
replaced David Trace, Wayne Summers, Andrew Perry, David Acton and
Natascha Kearsey. A correct decision?

--- In gevincountdown@..., "gevinchapwell"
<gevinchapwell@...> wrote:
>
> If 20 top Countdowners of all time, all playing at their best (it
> doesn't matter that they played at different times - this is just
a
> hypothetical situation where they are all at their peak), competed
> against each other in a league, what do you think the results
would
> be? In the league everyone would play everyone else, so it
wouldn't
> have the random factor of a knockout. Here are 20 of the all time
> greats (not necessarily the top 20 but I think the top handful
would
> be in this list) - what do you think the top few on the
leaderboard
> would be?
>
> 1. Mark Nyman
> 2. David Trace
> 3. Harvey Freeman
> 4. John Clarke
> 5. Nic Brown
> 6. Allan Saldanha
> 7. Tim Morrissey
> 8. Wayne Summers
> 9. Don Reid
> 10. Andrew Perry
> 11. David Acton
> 12. Natascha Kearsey
> 13. Scott Mearns
> 14. Graham Nash
> 15. David Williams
> 16. Tom Hargreaves
> 17. Chris Wills
> 18. Julian Fell
> 19. Chris Cummins
> 20. Stewart Holden
>
> Personally I think Julian Fell would come out on top. He's
obviously
> beatable as Graham Nash proved, but over the long haul I think
he'd
> come out on top. As for second, I think the two most likely
> candidates would be Harvey Freeman and Allan Saldanha (playing
like
> he did at the supreme championships).
>





Sun Nov 26, 2006 1:53 pm

gevinchapwell
Offline Offline
Send Email Send Email

Forward
Message #9268 of 9304 |
Expand Messages Author Sort by Date

If 20 top Countdowners of all time, all playing at their best (it doesn't matter that they played at different times - this is just a hypothetical situation...
gevinchapwell
Offline Send Email
Jul 25, 2004
5:32 pm

I think Dag Griffiths, Kate Ogilvie and Ben Wilson should have been included as well. Scott Mearns certainly deserves to be there - not sure about Natascha...
Dave Weaving
dave_weaving
Offline Send Email
Jul 25, 2004
7:49 pm

Sigh... At the risk of appearing a sourpuss, Natascha at 12...? The same Natascha that I beat by a margin of 35 points in the semi-final of series 35...? Just...
peterfromseries35
itspetenice@...
Send Email
Jul 27, 2004
2:29 pm

It was in chronological order (at least approximately). That's why I said I thought Julian Fell would win after putting him 18th. ... Natascha that I beat...
gevinchapwell
Offline Send Email
Jul 27, 2004
6:49 pm

In that case... I register my disapproval. You can't argue with 35 points, in the one match that really mattered....
peterfromseries35
itspetenice@...
Send Email
Jul 28, 2004
8:41 am

It wasn't the one match that really mattered though, was it? It was a match that mattered but not the only one. What about the CofC final? Anyway, as I said...
gevinchapwell
Offline Send Email
Jul 29, 2004
5:01 pm

Well, the C of C would have been nice but to me, it wasn't in the same league as winning an entire series. I was out clubbing the night before the final until...
peterfromseries35
itspetenice@...
Send Email
Jul 29, 2004
8:10 pm

Natascha appeared to be an introvert on the show, but she always seemed quite gracious in her manners, just like Scott Mearns or more recent Countdown...
Dave Weaving
dave_weaving
Offline Send Email
Jul 29, 2004
10:27 pm

I still think her win over Scott was her best game. When she played in her series and the CofC, I think all of her scores were very average. But I do think she...
gevinchapwell
Offline Send Email
Jul 31, 2004
10:43 am

... I wouldn't want to comment too specifically on who is or isn't in the top 20 and I wouldn't dream of offering myself but I do have a couple of comments. ...
Evan Simpson
m28ale
Offline Send Email
Jul 26, 2004
2:47 pm

The 20 names I put are by no means what I consider to be a definitive top 20. I thought went to Mike's page and picked them out fairly quickly. You could spend...
gevinchapwell
Offline Send Email
Jul 26, 2004
6:28 pm

... definitive ... include. ... finals ... Champions. ... inclusion. ... in ... of ... had ... beat ... Lawrence ... to ... It's an interesting list with many...
anthonyendsor
Offline Send Email
Jul 26, 2004
8:49 pm

I'd like to see some of the youngsters (younger than 15) that did well come back and see how a few more years experience have benefited them. Probably an...
Ian Gilmore
calaban10
Offline Send Email
Jul 29, 2004
10:54 pm

Here's an old top 20 list I came up with. It seems that Paul Gallen, Mark Tournoff, Conor Travers, Paul Howe and Matthew Shore have replaced David Trace, Wayne...
gevinchapwell
Offline Send Email
Nov 26, 2006
2:00 pm
Advanced

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! UK. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help