Sign In
New User? Sign Up
imperialrome2 · Imperial Rome
? Already a member? Sign in to Yahoo!

Yahoo! Groups Tips

Did you know...
You can schedule a time for the group to chat?

Messages

  Messages Help
Advanced
Messages 1500 - 1530 of 27291   Oldest  |  < Older  |  Newer >  |  Newest
Messages: Simplify | Expand   (Group by Topic) Author Sort by Date ^
1500
Relatively homogenous is itself definitely relative. Even after the Arab defeats, Byzantium held pockets of Italy, the Illyrian coast, non-Greek Balkan ...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
5:36 pm
1501
Check this URL out -- you may want to bookmark it:<br><br><a href=http://www.roman-emperors.org/battles.htm...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
5:37 pm
1502
Actually, a fair amount of the army at Chalons was Celto-Roman. And, a fair portion of the "barbarians" had been federates for at least one full generation....
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
5:39 pm
1503
Adrianople occurred in 378, prior to the division of the Empire and inception of an essentially new Greek empire. It was only from that point on that its ...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
5:45 pm
1504
All states have occasional traitors. But Byzantium enjoyed more support than the West....
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
5:48 pm
1505
It would seem to me, that an exploratory military campaign would be more of a probe into unknown territory. Its main function being, searching out resources, ...
paulrevere1985
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
5:58 pm
1506
If what you posit below is the case, that patrotism, or some ancient version of 19th century ideas of elan vital or Schopenhauerian "will" was the key ...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
6:03 pm
1507
Do you have historical documentation of the high level of Byzantine patriotism?...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
6:04 pm
1508
It is correct that the Muslims were kept at bay in the 8th century, along the Taurus Range, a natural mountain barrier that had served the earlier united Roman...
khakiberetman
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
6:14 pm
1509
I wasn't thinking of Spengler, but perhaps you can explain this idea some more/ I think it is a valid proposal... Why isn't it rational?...
khakiberetman
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
6:16 pm
1510
Badon is usually dated around 517, Camlamm around 537-39. So it does apprear a resistance by a pro-Roman party continued till then. There is also the ...
richard_roper
Offline Send Email
Feb 18, 2002
11:26 pm
1511
I think that the model of Rome as a corperation is a valid one if applied to the late Republic and this includes a faid amount of coporate backstabbing. that...
gauiscaecilius
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
12:41 pm
1512
True, "ethnic purity" is not a prerequisite for patriotism-America is a far better example than Switzerland-but in the absence of an effective common...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
4:37 pm
1513
The Byzantine army eclipsed that of the Western Empire in size and strength long before the time of Justinian. Most of the western(barbarian) army actually ...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
4:50 pm
1514
It makes no rational sense to suppose that Rome(or Classical civilization)just "grew old and died." A civilization is not a single organism....
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
4:54 pm
1515
I don't think "pro-Roman party" is an apt characterization so long after the disappearance of Roman authority in the West. Roman relics may be better....
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
4:57 pm
1516
Justinian still looked to "barbarians" for most of his cavalry. Rome itself had done that since the time of Julius Caesar....
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
6:16 pm
1517
I don't know if you missed post 1508 in which I discussed the structure of the Byzantine army, and its obligatory multi-ethnic composition. as has been said ...
khakiberetman
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
9:23 pm
1518
A civilisation is indeed not a single organism, but it is a creation of people and reflects their personalities. When I suggest that the "Roman order" aged to...
khakiberetman
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
9:28 pm
1519
Khaki, I made the same point as you did about the Roman cavalry being German since Caesar's day....
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 19, 2002
9:38 pm
1521
On the 18th March 2002 the imperial rome club will have been in operation for a year. It would be nice to to celebrate that fact in some way and Since we are...
gauiscaecilius
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
12:40 pm
1522
Mostly when faced by the name Brutus we tend to think about Marcus Junius Brutus that 'noblest Roman of them all' however the name belonmgs to a very old ...
gauiscaecilius
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
12:56 pm
1523
Yet the bulk of the Roman army was composed of Italians or Romanized provincials until the fourth and fifth centuries, when barbarians, often under their own ...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
4:39 pm
1524
But what about the bulk of the Byzantine army? Romans long had German bodyguards and foreign numeri but they were secondary to the Italian core of the army. ...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
4:59 pm
1525
You just don't want to give up or modify your view, do you? I have no problems seeing "patriotism," or something akin to it, as **part** of the difference...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
5:01 pm
1526
It certainly seems the most important factor to me. Any more specific counterarguments?...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
5:05 pm
1527
I think I, and other members of this group, have offered a number of counterarguments to your claims about "Greek purity," as well as to your claims against...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
5:32 pm
1528
But I addressed those counterarguments e.g. the unwillingnes of the rich in the West to pay taxes, and the extreme scarcity of anyone other than untrustworthy ...
uwrk
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
6:07 pm
1529
The "Greek" character of the Byzantine Empire, in particular, was underscored by westerners who competed with it, both in religion and in politics. That was ...
khakiberetman
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
6:48 pm
1530
Well, I in general don't like reducing comparisons of major changes, whether history, philosophy or whatever, to single causes. I don't see the world as...
stevesnyder63
Offline Send Email
Feb 20, 2002
8:08 pm
Messages 1500 - 1530 of 27291   Oldest  |  < Older  |  Newer >  |  Newest
Advanced
Add to My Yahoo!      XML What's This?

Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! UK. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy - Terms of Service - Guidelines - Help