I have just posted a commentary on the Severn Barrage
concept on my policy blog: “Case for the Severn Barrage –
does it hold water?” taking a sceptical view of the project as a
response to climate change. Here is the link….
If you would like to discuss this, please comment on the
blog not on this forum. This forum is intended for information and news
sharing, not discussion.
Two recent stories related to wave power that could be relevant to future policy on tidal stream, and will be of interest to marine energy enthusiasts more generally:
The SDC can now confirm that it will be launching its report on tidal power on Monday 1st October at 10.30am. There will be simultaneous press events in both London and Cardiff, and the report will be available on our website as a PDF around this time. Hard copies will follow shortly, although people will be able to order these in advance from our website.
For any media enquiries, please contact Rhian Thomas on 020 7270 8539.
Please note that due to preparations for the launch I will be very busy over the next few days and may be unable to answer emails until next week.
As you will all hopefully have heard, the SDC launched its report on tidal power in the UK yesterday, which picked up some excellent media coverage on the BBC (TV and radio), Channel 4 News, and most of the national broadsheets. The press release is attached.
I just wanted to let this group know that there will be a delay of a couple of weeks until we have hard copies available. However, you can order this now (for free) via a form on our website. Or you can download the report and the evidence base (including the engagement report we commissioned) at PDF files. Up to three hard copies of the report can be ordered on the website, but if you need more then just email edward.clarke@... and we'll add you to the list.
Many thanks to all those who sent us evidence or helped us in whatever way on this project. I hope the report will be a useful contribution to the debate. If you would like to comment on the report, then please could I encourage you to do this via our forum, at http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/forum_public/index.php?tid=1871.
Kind regards,
Oliver Knight
sustainabledevelopment commission The independent government advisor on sustainable development
THE SDC HAS MOVED - Please note my new contact details below
Oliver Knight Senior Policy Analyst - Energy & Transport Sustainable Development Commission (SDC) 55 Whitehall, London SW1A 2HH
>From Andrew[Ferrand] Stobart, Orleton, Leominster, Herefordshire UK
+44(0)1 568 780837
Yesterday the village held it’s annual Renewable Energy Celebration
generally kown as the Harvest Festival. The latest since the
rebuilding of the Church about 700 years ago, and possibly going back
in one form or another to the village foundation in it’s present layout
over 4000 years ago.
The Renewable Energy Harvest is everlasting, see Genesis VIII v.22 But
all too often the situation is as described in St. Mathew’s Gospel, IX
v.37 We should all now recognise that in Energy Matters exploitation is
no longer wholly viable, and that we should return to greater
Harvesting.
Day by day the mighty Sun, in his heavenly course does run
Winds rain heat upon us fall, a worthy Harvest for us all
And the silver Moon by night doth mighty tides keep flowing right
Nature’s mercies stll endure ever faithful ever sure
[Based on Hymns A & M No. 381 – tune traditional for Harvest Time]
Members of this group may be interested to read the most recent entry by the SDC's Chairman on the subject of our tidal report and the compensatory habitat issue. Please post any comments you may have to Jonathon's blog.
I have posted a critical commentary on the treatment of economics and financing of the Severn Barrage in the SDC report on tidal power. It's on my 'bacon butty' policy blog: Severn barrage - flawed economics
If you want to comment or put me a different view, please use the comment facility on the blog rather than post here. This Yahoo! group is for posting information, not debate.
Please note that the final two SDC-commissioned research reports supporting our Tidal Power in the UK project were uploaded to our website late last week. These are Research Reports 4 and 5, which look at Severn non-barrage options, and other UK case studies respectively.
We have also recently uploaded a revised version of our final report, which has taken care of a number of minor design errors. The hard copies have been ordered, but unfortunately won't be available for a couple more weeks. However, we'll be posting these out to everyone who has requested one through our website as soon as we receive them.
Finally, if you have any suggestions for general links to tidal power information that you feel would be a good addition to our website, then please let me know. We can only link to non-commercial, non-campaigning websites that contain authoratitive information on the subject.
Many thanks,
Oliver Knight
sustainabledevelopment commission The independent government advisor on sustainable development
THE SDC HAS MOVED - Please note my new contact details below
Oliver Knight Senior Policy Analyst - Energy & Transport Sustainable Development Commission (SDC) 55 Whitehall, London SW1A 2HH
I will be out of the office starting 12/10/2007 and will not return until
31/10/2007.
I am out of the office and will have limited access to my e mails, I will
respond to your message when I return, alternatively if it is urgent you
can contact Holly Newton on +44(0)1392 284 421.
I will be out of the office starting 12/10/2007 and will not return until
22/10/2007.
If your query is urgent please contact Ron Peddie on 01847 806617
Donna
This message has been scanned for viruses by BlackSpider MailControl -
www.blackspider.com
Enter your vote today! A new poll has been created for the
tidal_power_uk group:
Are you happy with the SDC's position (as outlined in its final report published
on 1st October 2007) on a Severn barrage?
o Yes, very
o Yes, somewhat
o No, somewhat
o No, very
To vote, please visit the following web page:
http://uk.groups.yahoo.com/group/tidal_power_uk/surveys?id=1936864
Note: Please do not reply to this message. Poll votes are
not collected via email. To vote, you must go to the Yahoo! Groups
web site listed above.
Thanks!
The Marine Environmental Data Action Group (MEDAG) is pleased to announce that they have published a GIS application that catalogues available tide and sea level data around the UK coast giving timescales, instrument, contact and other details. This compliments a catalogue of wave data, and a previously released DVD that contains over 4000 current meter data series and the software to explore and extract those data.
We hope that the Tidal Power UK group will find these data resources usefull.
-- This message (and any attachments) is for the recipient only. NERC
is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and the contents
of this email and any reply you make may be disclosed by NERC unless
it is exempt from release under the Act. Any material supplied to
NERC may be stored in an electronic records management system.
PRASEG Seminar: “Tidal Power in the UK: The Severn Barrage”
Date:Monday, 26 November 2007
Time: 4.30-6pm
Location:Committee Room 10, House of Commons
Please enter the House via the St Stephen’s entrance, and allow approximately 10-15 minutes to pass through security. You do not require identification, but it may be useful to have a copy of this e-mail with details of the seminar.
Synopsis:
Following the recent publication of the report “Tidal power in the UK” by the Sustainable Development Commission and Government’s announcement of a new feasibility study into the Severn Barrage, this seminar will look at potential tidal power resources and technologies within the context of creating a sustainable energy policy in the UK.
Guest Speaker:Malcolm Wicks MP, Minister of State for Energy
Speakers:
*Bernie Bulkin, Commissioner for Energy, Sustainable Development Commission
* Roger Hull, Spokesperson, Severn Tidal Power Group
* Martin Harper, Head of Sustainable Development, RSPB
Please see the attached news release, which refers to the PM's announcement on Monday (19th) on the economic potential of renewables and CCS. As part of this, BERR have announced that they will provide extra support under the Renewables Obligation to tidal lagoons and barrages under 1GW in capacity.
The SDC's report on tidal power recommended that Government look to support the development of one or more tidal lagoon demonstration projects. The challenge now lies with the renewables industry and those involved with tidal lagoons to develop a viable tidal lagoon project that successfully demonstrates the concept at scale.
Oliver Knight
sustainabledevelopment commission The independent government advisor on sustainable development
THE SDC HAS MOVED - Please note my new contact details below
Oliver Knight Senior Policy Analyst - Energy & Transport Sustainable Development Commission (SDC) 55 Whitehall, London SW1A 2HH
Please note that there has been a room change and the seminar will now take place in Committee room 5.
From: Knight, Oliver (SDC) Sent: 20 November 2007 12:58 To: tidal_power_uk@... Subject: PRASEG seminar: "Tidal Power in the UK: The Severn Barrage" - 26th November
PRASEG Seminar: “Tidal Power in the UK: The Severn Barrage”
Date:Monday, 26 November 2007
Time: 4.30-6pm
Location:Committee Room 10, House of Commons
Please enter the House via the St Stephen’s entrance, and allow approximately 10-15 minutes to pass through security. You do not require identification, but it may be useful to have a copy of this e-mail with details of the seminar.
Synopsis:
Following the recent publication of the report “Tidal power in the UK” by the Sustainable Development Commission and Government’s announcement of a new feasibility study into the Severn Barrage, this seminar will look at potential tidal power resources and technologies within the context of creating a sustainable energy policy in the UK.
Guest Speaker:Malcolm Wicks MP, Minister of State for Energy
Speakers:
*Bernie Bulkin, Commissioner for Energy, Sustainable Development Commission
* Roger Hull, Spokesperson, Severn Tidal Power Group
* Martin Harper, Head of Sustainable Development, RSPB
Does anyone know when the most recent current velocity survey
performed along the proposed Severn Barrage site and what type of
survey it was, i.e. Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler, Current Meter,
etc.?
BERR's response to the consultation on the banding of the Renewables Obligation was published recently. It announced support of two ROCs for tidal impoundments (barrages and lagoons) up to 1GW in size. The size restriction is in recognition of the fact that a large tidal barrage scheme (such as a proposed Severn barrage) would have an adverse impact on the operation of the RO - this is consistent with the advice from the Sustainable Development Commission in its October 2007 report.
Oliver Knight
sustainabledevelopment commission The independent government advisor on sustainable development
Oliver Knight Senior Policy Analyst - Energy & Transport Sustainable Development Commission (SDC) 55 Whitehall, c/o 3-5 Whitehall Place, London SW1A 2HH
sustainabledevelopment commission The independent government advisor on sustainable development
Oliver Knight Senior Policy Analyst - Energy & Transport Sustainable Development Commission (SDC) 55 Whitehall, c/o 3-5 Whitehall Place, London SW1A 2HH
I will be out of the office starting 31/01/2008 and will not return until
25/02/2008.
I am out of the office and will have limited access to my e mails, I will
respond to your message when I return, alternatively if it is urgent you
can contact Holly Newton on +44(0)1392 284 421.
Article in South Wales Evening Post
BAY LAGOON BACKER CALLS FOR POLICY SEA CHANGE
Date : 26.07.08
BY Richard YOULE environment reporter
richard.youle@...
THE man behind a proposed energy-generating lagoon in Swansea Bay
says he hasn't given up on the project, despite continuing silence
from the UK Government on the scheme.
Peter Ullman wants to capture rising and falling tides in a rocky
lagoon structure that would then funnel the water through turbines to
generate clean electricity for thousands of city homes.
Mr Ullman, chief executive of American firm Tidal Electric, was
speaking in the wake of an announcement by the Government of 10
potential schemes it is investigating to harness the huge tidal range
of the Severn Estuary.
They include the much-vaunted Severn barrage, running from Lavernock
Point, near Cardiff, to Brean Down, near Weston-super-Mare, a longer
barrage from Minehead, Somerset, to Aberthaw, in the Vale of
Glamorgan, a series of tidal lagoons, and a tidal reef.
The shortlist of 10 will be whittled down later this year, with
further feasibility studies taking place until late 2009 or early
2010.
The Swansea Bay project is not included in this shortlist because it
is not in the Severn Estuary. But because it's not part of the
ongoing government investigation, which has effectively put all the
schemes on hold, it could in theory get underway quickly if consent
was given.
"We have been ready to go for years," said Mr Ullman. "The issue for
us is whether we can get consent - but you just don't know what the
UK Government is going to do."
Having consulted 55 different groups about the Swansea Bay lagoon
scheme, and had the project studied by five independent specialists,
Mr Ullman believes a change in government policy is needed to give
him - and potential investors - confidence. But he added: "I have not
given up on Swansea Bay."
Tidal Electric is hoping to build tidal lagoons in Canada and in the
Sea of Cortez, off Mexico. "The Mexican Government is proposing to be
our partner on a 500MW scheme, which is much bigger than the 60MW
Swansea Bay scheme," said Mr Ullman. "We are hoping to close the
deal."
There are other advantages of Tidal Lagoons. The walls of tidal lagoons
could support wind turbines, and the lagoons themselves fish farming. On
the East Coast of England they could also act as barriers to coastal
erosion, and this has been proposed to local councils in that area.
Construction in many cases could be using the "Mulberry" technique as
deployed on the Normandy Coast in 1944 to construct harbours.
regards
Ferrand, see www.grunweb.org.uk/page25.html
The empoundment can be made more cheaply and without the use of
concrete by using a Gabion Wall type construction, with dredged
material, or maybe loose rock, with an impermeable membrane
incorporated. This will reduce the carbon cost during construction.
If the wall is ever demolished the only concrete to dispose of will be
the turbine housing.
If wind turbines are constructed on the wall, they will need to be
piled, but this will still be cheaper than fabricating the wall of
concrete.
Re wind turbines on pond walls, if contra rotating units are used, which
are "arrays" on a framework with a low overturning moment, foundation
requirements are much reduced, Floating units can be considered, moored
to pond walls.
regards
Ferrand
A new application 'UKDMOS' showing details of UK marine monitoring programmes is live at www.ukdmos.org and may be used to identify existing data to be used for projects (eg tidal power EIAs) and to coordinate ongoing monitoring programmes better to save resources.
Monitoring programmes may be searched spatially using GIS and/or by organisation, parameter groups, frequency, start dates and other fields by use of the drop down menus on the search webpage. Locations of each monitoring programme are displayed using GIS and further details provided with links and contact details. Each individual point may be interrogated using the GIS. A download into a csv file is available which gives summary details of each programme as defiend by the users search criteria. If you wish to submit a monitoring programme please contact ukdmos@...UKDMOS is for the wider marine community and specifically a key output for the UK Marine Monitoring and Assessment Strategy (UKMMAS).
-- This message (and any attachments) is for the recipient only. NERC
is subject to the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and the contents
of this email and any reply you make may be disclosed by NERC unless
it is exempt from release under the Act. Any material supplied to
NERC may be stored in an electronic records management system.
The present activities of the Financial World remind one of the two
ladies of legend who earned a precarious living by taking in each
other's washing or the Ozzlum Bird, which flies in ever decreasing
circles until with a cry of Oozelum and a cloud of feathers it
vanishes up it's own fundament.
We have all confused Money with Real Wealth, especially the tax
gatherers who have enthusiastically backed the Oozelum, collecting
taxes each time it went round.
The result of all this for the UK is that it is "Broke",
The Office of National Statistics has UK assets, as of 2006 (the
latest stats available, and no doubt it'll be less now) as
£6.5trillion. Less residential property (£3.8trillion) leaves
£2.7trillion.
Net debt stands at £600billion, but to include public sector pensions,
PFI, Northern Rock etc takes that figure to £1.8trillion.
Add the £500billion figure that has been bandied around this week as a
guarantee to the banking sector and we get £2.3trillion.
The Burning Our Money blog on the website estimates this to rise to
£6.5trillion if all commericial bank debt is guaranteed. i.e Credit
Card Debt etc.
It's a depressing picture, do take a look at this:
http://tpa.typepad.com/waste/2008/10/maxxed.html –
Real Wealth comes from harvesting or mining, plus human effort.
Harvesting areas include the Land, The Oceans, and the Sky. Mining can
be by Land or Sea.
So to start collecting Real Wealth we must rapidly set on the Energy
Harvest. Those who advocate Nuclear should remember that it, central
fossil power stations, and large wind farms are preferred by
Politicians as they can tax the output. Large wind farms are probably
uneconomic in principle as compared to many other Renewable
Engineering Projects
Trouble is that the UK Government has done little or nothing to set on
this Harvest other than form a new department for Climate Change and
Energy headed by someone who has no apparent knowledge or connection
with Energy or Harvesting, and may well be himself – and presiding
over- one of a tream of scientific analphabets.
THEY MOAN ABOUT A FORTHCOMING DEPRESSION.
BUT WITH MOST UK DWELLINGS LACKING SOLAR WATER HEATING, SOLAR PANELS,
AND HEAT PUMPS. TIDAL POWER UNDEVELOPED. WIND POWER TOO COSTLY.
BIOFUELS FROM CO2 UNDEVELOPED ETC. HOW CAN WE HAVE A DEPRESSION -
OTHER THAN THROUGH FAILURE OF POLITICAL AND PRIVATE WILL TO TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF THE VAST MANUFACTURING, INSTALLATION AND OPERATIONAL
OPPORTUNITIES ON OFFER FROM RENEWABLE ENGINEERING ????
IT IS COUNTER INFLATIONARY TOO !!
Regards
Ferrand www.grunweb.org.uk
Ps feedback appreciated, especially on asset and debt data for other
countries.
I will be out of the office starting 07/11/2008 and will not return until
24/11/2008.
I am out of the office and will have limited access to my e mails, I will
respond to your message when I return, alternatively if it is urgent you
can contact Holly Newton on +44(0)1392 284 421.
----------------------------------------------------------
The information contained in this communication is intended solely for the
use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed and others
authorized to receive it. It may contain confidential or legally
privileged information. If you are not the intended recipient you are
hereby notified that any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking any
action in reliance on the contents of this information is strictly
prohibited and may be unlawful. If you have received this communication in
error, please notify us immediately by responding to this email and then
delete it from your system. Ernst & Young is neither liable for the proper
and complete transmission of the information contained in this
communication nor for any delay in its receipt.